There are several types of pool water options available to the pool owner. This article attempts to identify which is the most sensible option to choose
Types of pool water options to consider:
1. Fresh water, where you add granular or tablet chlorine to the water in order to keep it sanitized and clear.
2. Salt water, where you add salt to the pool water and an electrode array creates the sanitation.
3. Ozone pool, where sanitation is created by Ozone which is made from Oxygen or O2, which is converted through electricity to Ozone or O3. Ozone is a much more powerful oxidant than chlorine. Ozone dissipates very quickly. It must be manufactured and used on-site, and generators can now be purchased from specialist suppliers which can be fitted into an existing pool pipework without too much effort or cost. Ozone Generators convert the Oxygen in the air into Ozone.
4. Ultraviolet, where the pool water passes through a cylinder that contains an ultraviolet light tube, the ultraviolet rays kill the harmful organic elements suspended in the water
5. Swimming ponds where a selection of naturally growing plants create the sanitation. In warmer climate mosquito larvae eating fish must be present otherwise mosquitoes can become unbearable close to the pool.
For the purposes of this article we are looking at the first two options, standard fresh water and salt water.
How do they work.
Traditionally, Europeans tend to opt for the standard fresh water option. This is where you fill your basin with standard mains water or can buy it in from a water supplier in a tanker. Whichever, this is basic drinking water.
The water has to be treated continuously for a pleasant bathing experience in clear water that is free from both water borne insects such as mosquito larvae or microscopic animals such as bacteria or plants such as algae. If left untreated the water will deteriorate quickly will become discolored and will be less than healthy or pleasant to swim in.
There are two things that your fresh water pool owner needs to continuously monitor, both of which are vital. Firstly pH. This is important for several reasons, but the main reason is that anything outside the recommended pH level of 7.4 will make any additional chlorine added to the water for sanitation less effective. So the number one operation is to check the pH level and to add pH plus or minus depending on the test result. Many pool owners skip this test believing it unimportant thinking as long as you throw plenty of chlorine at the pool everything else will be OK, this is far from the truth and will cost you significantly more as the available chlorine in an unbalanced pool will need to work much harder.
Usually the same tester kit has the facility for measuring the chlorine level. This is usually achieved by adding Chlorine tablets, this can be put in the skimmer pots or a purpose floating applicator. It is always best to buy the 4 action tablets as they contain the other additives generally required to maintain a good water balance and health, and saves having to purchase, store and handle these other chemicals individually.
There are other tests that can be done and some good swimming pool shops will offer a water testing service if you pool water has become a problem that is defeating you. But keep these two elements always correct and occasionally test for TOTAL pH and you should have trouble free bathing.
The mechanics behind a salt water pool is frequently misunderstood. For example I will share a conversation I had recently. I received a call from a pool owner who was having big algae problems with his saltwater pool . The first question I asked was “have you checked the salt level or added any salt recently” His reply was astonishing “My pool is a saltwater pool, it has a mechanism that makes salt that keeps the water clean and healthy.” He was astonished when I explained how his system actually worked, but his astonishment was nothing compared to mine when he told me he had had the system for almost fifteen years, and he admitted he had always been puzzled when previous pool companies had added sacks of salt to his pool when he had had problems before, but nobody had ever explained what he had, and he clearly had never bothered to find out.
Basically salt water pools work like this: You have to install a unit into your pool filter line which contains an array of titanium electrodes. You then add several sacks of raw rough salt granules into the fresh water in your pool. A 50m3 pool requires about 250kg of salt. The electrodes are activated by a low voltage power supply when the pool pump comes on and drives the now salted water through and over the electrode plates. The electrodes split the salt molecules from sodium chloride or NaCl into sodium and chlorine Na and Cl. There is a control module that comes with the kit which indicates the level of salt in the water, so you will know when to add more, and the chlorine production level.
So you can see you are still achieving the sanitation by using chlorine. But the chlorine is much healthier, in fact it is almost completely indiscernible in the water, and anyone that gets agitated by the fact that there is still chlorine in the water and therefore this is a flawed and less than environmental solution are misinformed. The environmental issues normally associated with Chlorine in its synthetic form come from its manufacture, health problems from its handling, and unpleasant side effects including skin irritation, sore eyes and horrible smell come from the stabilizers and the trichlorides that form with its usage. None of these apply in the Chloride made in a salt water pool system. This leads us neatly into the following considerations
The considerations when choosing your system are as follows: Swimming environment, health, Initial start-up costs, Ongoing costs, convenience of maintenance.
So lets make the first comparison based on the swimming environment. It appears that most people who have had the experience of bathing in both types of pool, i.e. fresh water sanitized with synthetic chlorine and a salt water pool, myself included, seem to prefer the salt water experience. As already discussed, freshwater pools where chlorine is added in a synthetic form of granules or tablets can cause irritation to skin and eyes, dry the skin when leaving the pool and leave your body and clothes smelling bad. It can also bleach your hair and clothes and shorten the life of your costume and pool toys significantly. One of the main reasons I personally looked into alternatives was that every time I handled the chlorine, I would usually get at least one big lungful of chlorine gas,usually when removing a tight lid, and would get infuriated when constantly spoiling decent trousers or shirts with white spots from the chlorine.
The salt water pool has salinity very similar to that that is contained in the human body, or about 1/10 of that that you find in the sea. Consequently you are swimming in almost fresh water. In fact there is no danger if swallowed, and it can even be put onto grass and plants without them suffering any harm at all. No stinging eyes, no bad smelling hair or skin and your body feels lovely cleansed and fresh when ever you get out of the pool.
So round one to the salt water pool.
The next consideration is health. Some of the statistics that are now available make some very interesting if not scary reading. Chlorine byproducts found in fresh water swimming pools are linked to higher incidences of asthma, lung damage, stillbirths, miscarriages and bladder cancer, according to credible research conducted in the U.S., Canada, Norway, Australia and Belgium.
One researcher noted that 10-year-old children spending an average of 1.8 hours per week in an indoor swimming pool environment suffered lung damage she would expect to see in an adult smoker.
The problem isn’t the chlorine, but what chlorine turns into when combined with organics. The organics are contributed by bathers in the pool in the form of sweat, dander, urine and other organics. The chlorine reacts with the organics and produces nitrogen trichloride, aldehydes, halogenated hydrocarbons, chloroform, trihalomethanes and chloramines. If these sound like dangerous chemicals, they are. During the Olympic Games held in Australia, it was reported that more than one-quarter of the American swim team suffered from some degree of asthma.
Investigators in Belgium presented research showing that exposure to such chloramines greatly increases permeability of the lung epithelium, a condition normally associated with smoking cigarettes.
In contrast a salt water pool which generates much lower levels of chlorine, which is much better distributed throughout the whole body of water by nature of the method of production, under these standards, the salt water swimming pool water is essentially treated to drinking water standards, and although not such a good solution from a health perspective as the ultraviolet or ozone options is significantly better than using synthetic chlorine pool products manually added to fresh water.
Round two, health, to the salt water option. Two nil.
Initial start up costs are marginal for a fresh water pool as no additional equipment is needed unless you invest in a tablet applicator, which are very inexpensive. Salt water pool equipment is now less expensive than it has been. For a 50m3 pool, which represents about 75% of the European pool install base, or a 8m x 4m by average 1.5m depth pool will cost about Euros 1000 for all the kit and a further euros 100.00 for the salt. They are quite simple to install and most people should be able to do this themselves.
Round three to the freshwater pool. Two – one.
Ongoing costs.
Many people just look at the costs of the chemicals that they have to put into a fresh water pool during the swimming season, which for a standard 50m3 pool will be in the region of about euros 300.00. For me this pales into insignificance when you add the costs of the numerous pairs of jeans and new shirts that have been ruined every year by handling pool chemicals. “I’ll just put some chlorine in the pool, I’ll be careful as I cant be bothered to change just for this quick simple job” only to regret it virtually every time when the tell tale white blotches and smears appear on that favorite piece of clothing.
One thing you will have to do with a salt water pool is install an automatic pH dosing unit. These basically monitor the pH very accurately and add pH minus, or acid, because the by product of the chlorinator is alkaline caused by sodium carbonate. Because the Chlorine dosage from the unit is so mild this is important otherwise you can quickly have problems if this falls out of line. I believe this would be a useful addition to any pool so will not count this as a cost against the salt system. If you use a diluted form of Salfumant (Hydrochloric acid) the ongoing costs here are marginal. To conclude on this point, a salt water pool hardly has any ongoing costs, whereas the cost of chemicals, time, and replacing clothing can be significant over the year,
Round four to the salt water pool. Three - one
Onto the final consideration, convenience. The time saved in not having to manually put chemicals into the water and test the levels constantly are significant. No shopping for chemicals, and no replacing of clothing - great.
Round five to the salt water pool. Four – one
In conclusion. I am happy to conclude and therefore recommend that based on the score four - one, a salt water pool is a better option. Even if you take the point conceded on capital costs, if you shop around you can buy these systems for less now. Also if you factor in the savings from the reduction to almost zero for ongoing costs the capital will be paid off very quickly, lets say two years, therefore in reality fresh water pools need to concede another point, five – one. Its a landslide!
I have had my salt water system for one season now having changed from a standard chemical devouring freshwater pool, and do I regret it? – not one bit, it does all the positive things mentioned in detail above, and everyone loves the water quality – it just feels so much healthier, probably because it is. I spend far less time on the pool now and I know I am saving money.
I will say though that you may need to run the filter pump for longer, which is an additional power cost. I have also found that it is a good idea to add 5l of liquid bleach to the pool a week. This can be bought from any supermarket for about one euro, the cheaper the better, and try and get the odorless type. This keeps everything A OK and the sparkliest water ever without compromising the ethics of your new system.
Statistics show that the Australians are far further advanced than we are in Europe regarding which type of pool we like to have, with the Aussies having over 75% of their pools as salt water systems. Current statistics on numbers of installed pools across Europe - and for the purposes of this study this includes, Spain and its islands (Canaries and Balearics) Portugal, France , Italy and the UK show that the number of adopters of salt water systems across this region to be less than 20%.
Calyenty is a premium supplier of swimming pool heating systems based on heat pump technology. We manufacturer powerful whisper quiet, titanium heart, stainless steel cabinet heaters for distribution across Spain, and its islands (including Mallorca, Minorca, Ibiza, Tenerife, Lanzerote, Palma etyc.) Portugal, France, UK and the rest of Europe.